It's increasingly clear that regulators have woken up to the risks posed by a systemic cyber event. From a number of recent statements, it's clear that cyber insurance providers need to do more than showing evidence of capacity on paper. They also need to demonstrate that they'll be able to respond effectively in the event of major market disruption.
This matters because the next severe cyber event may not look like the last one. A large-scale ransomware campaign, cloud outage, software supply chain compromise, or managed service provider failure could generate thousands, if not millions, of claims notifications in hours rather than days.
Regulators are raising the bar
The FCA's latest statements clearly underline how operational resilience is moving up the agenda. In its 2026 Insurance Regulatory Priorities report, the regulator included claims handling and service quality among its headline focus areas, stating explicitly that firms need to be able to respond promptly, fairly, and transparently to claims and queries, and to ensure that their products will deliver what's been promised. The FCA also made clear that claims handling is very much an active supervisory issue, with investigations, remediation activity and outcome monitoring - and scope for further market-wide action.
The challenge of a systemic cyber event
During a systemic event, cyber insurance processes to triage and resolve claims will be tested under surge pressure. They will be judged on their ability to perform at a time when inboxes are overflowing, call volumes are spiking, external vendors are stretched, and claimants are looking for urgent guidance.
The FCA's new PS26/2 reporting regime goes further. The regulator has emphasised that it needs better, more accurate and consistently structured data to understand the growing interconnectedness of the industry - and to identify and address systemic risk. The FCA has said that the new data will help it triage incidents at pace, rapidly identify wider disruption to consumers and markets, and better understand linkages and dependencies created by third parties.
In other words, regulators want earlier visibility of spreading disruption, especially where shared suppliers or outsourced services could affect multiple businesses at once.
Meanwhile, the UK's proposed Cyber Security and Resilience Bill is expected to bring more managed service providers into scope of stronger cyber obligations and incident reporting requirements. The direction of travel is consistent: where operational failure has the potential to cascade across multiple organisations, resilience expectations are rising.
Response ecosystem concentration
There is, however, a practical challenge. Cyber insurance response processes rely on a relatively small and overlapping ecosystem of specialist law firms, forensic investigators, crisis communications providers, and remediation partners. Recent panel analysis has shown potentially concerning patterns of concentration. In one sample of five major cyber carriers, two law firms appeared on every panel reviewed. One forensic provider appeared on all five, and four others appeared on four out of five.
This approach may work fine under normal conditions. But a true market-wide event would create simultaneous demand for the same limited pool of expertise and resources across multiple carriers.
How can cyber insurers meet the new standard of operational resilience?
The first step is to scale the top of the funnel. Legacy FNOL processes often depend on manual intake, fragmented data capture, and human triage. In a surge scenario, this approach would likely create friction - precisely when speed and clarity matter most.
Insurers need to be able to handle incidents at scale, capture structured data from the outset, prioritise intelligently, and route cases quickly to those claimants most in need. That ability will play a crucial role in enabling faster claimant response, stronger communications, and better regulatory reporting.
Preparing for the next big test
If you're not already confident you can do all that, ACS FirstResponder can help. By modernising FNOL, enabling adaptive triage, and turning inbound demand into structured operational intelligence, ACS helps insurers build the resilience regulators increasingly expect.
With operational resilience increasingly in the spotlight, now is the time to review whether your response model is ready. Talk to ACS Cyber today about how ACS FirstResponder can help you prepare for the next major test.
Get started
Prepare for the next resilience test
Review whether your FNOL and surge response model can deliver the visibility, triage, and structured data regulators increasingly expect.